管自己Leading Self管团队Leading Teams管业务Leading Business
判断力Judgment学习力Learning自驱力Drive影响力Influence

管理者批评员工
要掌握技巧
Giving Critical
Feedback
That Works

这节课解决This lesson solves

该说的憋着不说,
一开口又变成了训人。
You hold back what needs saying,
then it comes out as a telling-off.

批评这件事,多数人要么憋着,要么炸了Most managers either bottle it up or blow up

印尼地区部INDONESIARizky 发给渠道销售部的销量周报,这个月第三次出错Rizky’s weekly sell-through report to Channel Sales is wrong for the third time this month
憋Hold什么都不说Say nothing

自己默默改好,记在心里,留到年底评估一起算。Quietly fix it, keep a mental note, save it all for the year-end review.

Rizky 根本不知道出了问题Rizky never learns there’s a problem

炸Blow当众甩一句Call it out in public

团队群里:「又错了,能不能上点心?」In the team chat: “Wrong again. Can you please pay attention?”

他丢了面子,还是不清楚错在哪一步He loses face and still doesn’t know what went wrong

两种做法,下个月的周报都会照样出错。Either way, next month’s report will be wrong again.

一个认知The one idea

批评,是为了下一次。Critical feedback is for next time.

三个常见的冒牌货THREE COMMON IMPOSTORS

发泄Venting

「你怎么总这样?」“Why are you always like this?”

对象是人,对方只顾着保护自己Aimed at the person, so they defend themselves

绕弯子Hinting

「最近要多注意哈。」“Just be a bit more careful lately.”

怕伤关系,对方没听出你在批评They never realize it was criticism

三明治Sandwich

夸一句 → 批评 → 再夸一句Praise → criticism → more praise

重点被盖住;以后一夸他,他就等「但是」The point gets buried; soon every compliment waits for a “but”

真正的批评Real critical feedback一个具体行为one specific behavior+它带来的影响its impact+一起定下的下一次an agreed next time
SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

对行为,不对人Behavior, not person

互动TRY IT · 0/3

标签让人辩护,事实才让人知道改哪里Labels make people defend. Facts show what to fix.

标签LABEL 01

「你太粗心了」“You’re so careless.”

↻点击翻面Tap to flip
事实FACT 01

周二发给渠道销售部的周报里,雅加达和泗水用了上个月的数据。In Tuesday’s report to Channel Sales, Jakarta and Surabaya used last month’s data.

不再说 「你太粗心了」Instead of “You’re so careless.”

能改的To fix发之前核对数据日期Check data dates before sending

标签LABEL 02

「你态度有问题」“You have an attitude problem.”

↻点击翻面Tap to flip
事实FACT 02

客户的投诉邮件周一就到了,你周四才回复。The customer complaint arrived Monday. You replied on Thursday.

不再说 「你态度有问题」Instead of “You have an attitude problem.”

能改的To fix当天先回一句「收到,在处理」Same-day reply: “Got it, on it.”

标签LABEL 03

「你太不靠谱了」“You’re so unreliable.”

↻点击翻面Tap to flip
事实FACT 03

答应周四给的门店名单,到周五下午还没有发出来。The store list you promised for Thursday still wasn’t sent by Friday afternoon.

不再说 「你太不靠谱了」Instead of “You’re so unreliable.”

能改的To fix做不完,提前一天说Can’t make it? Say so a day early

正面:管理者常说的标签Front: what managers often say背面:标签背后的那件事Back: the actual event behind it

SBI 反馈模型,再加一问一约The SBI model, plus Ask & Agree

SBI 反馈模型THE SBI MODEL

S

情境Situation

何时 · 何地When and where

B

行为Behavior

看到的具体做法What they did

I

影响Impact

带来的后果What it led to

SBI 之后 · 一问一约AFTER SBI

问Ask

问缘由Ask

先问对方怎么想How they saw it

约Agree

定下一步Agree

做法 · 时间 · 回头看What, when, check-in

下一次Next
time

行为真的变了The behavior changes

回头看 · 做到了就说一句CHECK IN · SAY IT WHEN IT’S FIXED

SBI 把发生了什么讲清楚,一问一约把它变成下一次。SBI makes clear what happened. Ask & Agree turn it into next time.

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME
SB

情境 + 行为:何时何地,做了什么Situation + Behavior: when, where, and what

一句事实句A fact statement

情境Situation什么时候 · 什么场合when · where+行为Behavior具体做了什么what was done
✕「你太粗心了。」“You’re so careless.”
✓「周二情境发给渠道销售部的周报里情境,雅加达和泗水用了上个月的数据行为。」“On Tuesday,SITUATION in the report to Channel Sales,SITUATION Jakarta and Surabaya used last month’s data.BEHAVIOR”
开口前删掉:Cut before you speak:总是always从来never态度attitude性格personality

一次一件ONE AT A TIME一次只说一件事,不翻三个月的旧账。One issue at a time. No digging up three months of history.

摄像机测试The camera test

✓ 拍得下来✓ On camera用了上个月的数据Used last month’s data
✕ 拍不下来✕ Not on camera「粗心」是你的判断“Careless” is your judgment
SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME
I

影响:讲清它带来的后果Impact: spell out what it led to

客户Customer
团队Team
他自己Them

他最在乎口碑:重点讲这一圈His reputation: lead here

光说事实,对方可能觉得「就一个小错,至于吗」。Facts alone can sound like “it’s just a small slip.”

对客户CUSTOMER

渠道伙伴按错的数字备了货Channel partners stocked up on the wrong numbers

对团队TEAM

渠道销售部的同事花了半天核对Channel Sales spent half a day re-checking

对他自己THEM

大家开始不太敢直接用他的周报People double-check his reports before using them

「我对你很失望。」“I’m really disappointed in you.”
这是你的情绪That’s your feeling
平静地讲后果
对方反而听得进去
State consequences calmly
They’re easier to hear
SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME
问Ask

SBI 之后,先问再判断After SBI, ask before you judge

SBII多一个 I:Intent 意图
先弄清对方当时怎么想
One more I: Intent
What were they thinking?

讲完 SBI,停下来问After the SBI, stop and ask

「当时是什么情况?」“What happened there?”「你怎么看?」“How do you see it?”
「你是不是没检查?」“Didn’t you check it?”

这不算问Not a question是把答案塞给了他It hands them your answer

然后真的听Then really listen急着接话 心里准备反驳jumping in drafting a rebuttal

他可能说HE MIGHT SAY

「系统数据每周二中午才更新,周报却要求上午发。」“The system only updates at noon on Tuesday, but the report is due in the morning.”

问题在流程,一起改流程It’s a process problem. Fix it together

也可能说OR HE MIGHT SAY

「是我没核对。」“I didn’t double-check.”

他自己认了,不用再往下压He’s owned it. No need to push

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME
约Agree

最后约定下一次,并且回头看Finally, agree on next time, and check in

一份好的约定A good agreement

具体做法WHAT周报改到周二下午发,发之前对一遍系统更新时间Send the report Tuesday afternoon, after confirming the system has updated
从何时起STARTING从下周起From next week
回头看CHECK-IN下周二,我看第一份Next Tuesday, I’ll review the first one

三样都要有:做法、开始时间、回头看的时间点。All three: what changes, when it starts, when you check in.

他先提They go first做法最好让他先提。自己想出来的办法,执行起来最用心。Let them suggest the fix. People follow through on their own ideas.
没改好?先回到「问」Not fixed? Back to Ask
今天谈Talk todaySBI · 问 · 约SBI · Ask · Agree
下周二Next Tuesday真的去看Actually look
说一句Say it「这次改好了。」“This one’s fixed.”

有这一句认可,这次批评才算有了结尾。That acknowledgment is what closes the loop.

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

真谈起来,常卡在三个地方Where real conversations get stuck

不管卡在哪,都别退回去贴标签。事实还是那个事实。Wherever it stalls, don’t fall back on labels. The fact is still the fact.

辩解Defensive「别人也这样」“Others do it too”

别去争别人,把话拉回这件事Don’t debate others. Bring it back

「今天先只谈这份周报。」“Today, let’s just talk about this report.”

沉默Silent一直不说话Says nothing

别替他说完,换一个更小的问题Don’t finish for them. Ask smaller

「哪一步最容易出错?」“Which part is easiest to get wrong?”

情绪Upset急了,或者难过Frustrated or hurt

先停下,承认感受,约明天接着谈Pause, acknowledge, resume tomorrow

「我们明天再接着聊。」“Let’s pick this up tomorrow.”

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

练一练Practice

互动TRY IT · 0/1

这段话,少了哪一步?Which step is missing?

独联体地区部,经理 Pavel 在视频里对 Aigerim 说:CIS region. Manager Pavel says to Aigerim on a video call:

「上周五交给零售管理部的门店巡检表,阿拉木图有四家店没填。他们这周要重新排巡店,耽误了两天。下周五之前补齐,以后每次提交前,自己再过一遍清单。」“Last Friday’s store audit sheet for Retail Management was missing four stores in Almaty. They’ve had to reschedule this week’s visits, which cost two days. Please complete it by next Friday, and run through the checklist yourself before every submission.”

答对了Correct再想想Not quitePavel 没问四家店为什么漏了。也许它们刚开业,还没进系统。先问,约定才会落在真正的原因上。Pavel never asked why the four stores were missing. Maybe they’d just opened and weren’t in the system yet. Ask first, so the agreement targets the real cause.

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

真实场景A real case

同一件事,两种谈法One incident, two conversations

西欧地区部。Amara 答应法国一家零售伙伴,周五送到新品样机。她没和产品交付与服务部确认,样机没到,门店的发布活动空了一个展台。Western Europe region. Amara promised a French retail partner demo units by Friday without checking with Product Delivery & Service. The units didn’t arrive, and the launch event had an empty display table.

两段谈话 · 时间差不多BOTH TALKS · ABOUT THE SAME TIME

✕只记住了难堪Only the embarrassment
✓团队多了一条规矩:承诺交期前先确认A new team rule: confirm lead times first
✕经理 Luca 的第一反应LUCA’S FIRST REACTION

「你怎么搞的?这都能出错。你做事太想当然了,以后别这样。」“What happened? How could this go wrong? You’re too quick to assume. Don’t let it happen again.”

贴标签Label没问原因No question没有下一步No next step

→ Amara 能记住的,只有难堪。→ All Amara takes away is embarrassment.

✓同一件事,SBI + 一问一约SAME TALK: SBI, THEN ASK & AGREE
SB

「周五法国那家门店的活动,你答应了样机周五到,事先没找交付的同事确认。」“For Friday’s event in France, you promised the demo units would arrive, without checking with the delivery team first.”

I

「样机没到,展台空了一个,伙伴临时换了陈列,下次合作会更谨慎。」“The units didn’t arrive, one table sat empty, and the partner will be more cautious with us next time.”

问Ask

「你当时是怎么判断周五能到的?」Amara:「我以为交付周期和上次一样。」“How did you decide Friday was doable?”Amara: “I assumed the lead time was the same as last time.”

约Agree

「以后承诺日期前,先找交付的同事确认。周五我们一起看新的排期表。」“Before promising dates, check with the delivery team first. On Friday, let’s review the new schedule together.”

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

练一练Practice

互动TRY IT · 0/1

会后找他谈,第一句怎么说?After the meeting, how do you open?

中东地区部周三的周会上,国际市场部的同事讲活动方案,Omar 两次打断:「这个根本做不了。」Middle East region, Wednesday’s weekly meeting. As a colleague from International Marketing presents a campaign plan, Omar interrupts twice: “This simply can’t be done.”

答对了Correct再想想Not quiteA 和 C 在评价人,D 等于没说。B 是一件双方都认的事实,谈话才有起点。A and C judge the person; D says nothing. B is a fact you both agree on, so the conversation has somewhere to start.

SBI+问Ask约Agree下一次NEXT TIME

练一练Practice

互动TRY IT · 0/1

当着外人的面,怎么做最合适?With outsiders present, what’s the best move?

东南亚地区部和渠道伙伴开视频会,Minh 报出的返点比例说错了。你就坐在他旁边。Southeast Asia region. On a video call with channel partners, Minh quotes the wrong rebate rate. You’re sitting right next to him.

答对了Correct再想想Not quite当着外人,只修正信息,保住他的面子。批评留到私下,而且当天就谈。In front of outsiders, fix the information and protect his standing. Save the feedback for a private talk, the same day.

我们的一句话口诀 · SBI + 一问一约OUR FOUR-LINE VERSION · SBI + ASK & AGREE

事Fact

事实开口Open with the facts.

S · B
果Impact

后果说透Spell out the impact.

I
问Ask

先问缘由Ask before you judge.

一问+ ASK
约Agree

约定再走Agree before you leave.

一约+ AGREE

谈之前,在心里默念一遍。Run through it before any tough conversation.

明天就能做的三件事,和这套方法的边界Three things for tomorrow, and where this stops

1

写一句事实句Write one fact statement

把最近想批评的那件事写下来:时间、场合、具体行为。删掉「总是」和「态度」。Take something you’ve meant to raise: when, where, what was done. Cut “always” and “attitude.”

2

约一个 15 分钟一对一Book a 15-minute one-on-one

当天或第二天就谈,私下谈,别攒到年底评估。Today or tomorrow, in private. Don’t save it for the year-end review.

3

谈完发一条消息Send a follow-up note

写下约定的做法和回看时间,到点真的去看。Write down what you agreed and when you’ll check in. Then follow through.

适用Use it for能改的行为和工作结果Behavior and work results that can change
合规、诚信问题Compliance or integrity按制度处理,拉上 HR 伙伴Follow formal process with your HR partner
约定几次还没改Same issue, several agreements转成正式的绩效改进Move to a formal performance plan
你自己还在气头上You’re still angry先等一晚,再谈Sleep on it, then talk
knowledge card

本节知识卡Knowledge card

一张卡,
谈之前看一眼
One card to check
before you talk

一个认知、SBI 和一问一约、口诀、明天的三件事和边界,都在上面。中英文各一张。The idea, SBI with Ask & Agree, the four lines, three actions for tomorrow, and the limits. In English and Chinese.

管理起手式 · 管团队 · 影响力MANAGEMENT STARTERS · LEADING TEAMS · INFLUENCE

管理者批评员工要掌握技巧Giving Critical Feedback That Works

批评是为了下一次,对行为,不对人Feedback is for next time: behavior, not person SBI:情境 · 行为 · 影响,再加一问一约SBI: Situation · Behavior · Impact, then Ask & Agree 卡住时别退回贴标签;当众只纠正信息When stuck, no labels; in public, only fix the facts

下一次想批评谁,先写下那句事实句。Next time, start by writing down the fact.

下节课再见See you next lesson